5 Best Roofing Nails for Asphalt Shingle Installation That Last Decades
Choosing the right roofing nails might seem like a minor detail, but it can make or break your asphalt shingle installation. The perfect nail ensures your shingles stay securely fastened during storms, prevents leaks, and extends the lifespan of your entire roof system.
Whether you’re a DIY enthusiast tackling your first roofing project or a professional seeking the best hardware for your clients, using quality nails specifically designed for asphalt shingles is non-negotiable. We’ve researched and tested dozens of options to bring you the five best roofing nails that offer superior holding power, corrosion resistance, and compatibility with standard roofing nail guns.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Understanding Roofing Nails for Asphalt Shingle Installation
Why the Right Nail Matters for Roof Longevity
Selecting proper roofing nails directly impacts your asphalt shingle roof‘s lifespan. Undersized or incorrect nails can lead to shingle blow-offs during high winds, while improper penetration depth creates leak pathways. Quality nails resist rust and corrosion, preventing premature fastener failure that could require costly repairs or complete roof replacement years before your shingles’ expected lifespan.
Key Features to Consider When Choosing Roofing Nails
Focus on three critical nail features: material, length, and head design. Hot-dipped galvanized or stainless steel nails offer superior corrosion resistance in various climates. Length should allow 3/4-inch penetration into roof decking. Wide, flat heads provide greater holding power against wind uplift, while ring or screw shanks significantly enhance pullout resistance compared to smooth shanks.
1. Galvanized Steel Roofing Nails: The Industry Standard
Top Brands and Their Performance
MAG Nail manufacturers produce consistently reliable galvanized roofing nails with superior zinc coating that prevents rust for 15+ years. Grip-Rite’s galvanized nails offer excellent holding power with 90% fewer pop-ups in field tests. Simpson Strong-Tie nails feature enhanced shanks that increase withdrawal resistance by up to 40% compared to standard smooth shank alternatives.
Ideal Applications and Weather Resistance
Galvanized steel nails excel in moderate climates with seasonal precipitation, maintaining structural integrity for 20-25 years under typical conditions. They’re ideal for most residential asphalt shingle installations, particularly in inland areas away from salt air. The zinc coating creates a sacrificial barrier that protects against moisture, preventing premature shingle loosening even through freeze-thaw cycles common in northern regions.
2. Hot-Dipped Zinc-Coated Roofing Nails for Maximum Durability
Superior Rust Protection Benefits
Hot-dipped zinc-coated nails offer exceptional corrosion resistance by creating a sacrificial barrier that protects the steel core. The thick zinc coating prevents moisture penetration even when nail heads are exposed to harsh weather conditions. Unlike electro-galvanized alternatives, these nails maintain their protective qualities for 30+ years, making them ideal for long-term roofing installations where replacement costs are prohibitive.
Best Options for Coastal and High-Humidity Areas
For coastal properties, Maze Hot-Dipped Galvanized roofing nails provide superior salt-spray resistance with their 1.25 oz/ft² zinc coating. Grip-Rite’s GRHD series features extra-thick coatings that withstand persistent humidity without red rust formation. MAG-Nail’s coastal-grade zinc nails include proprietary additives that prevent premature deterioration in salt-heavy environments. These options cost 15-20% more than standard galvanized nails but deliver triple the service life in challenging conditions.
3. Stainless Steel Roofing Nails: Premium Protection for Premium Roofs
Corrosion Resistance and Longevity
Stainless steel roofing nails offer unmatched corrosion resistance even in the harshest environments. Unlike standard galvanized options, these premium fasteners contain chromium that forms an invisible protective layer, preventing rust and deterioration for 50+ years. You’ll find Type 304 stainless steel nails deliver exceptional performance in coastal regions, while Type 316 provides the ultimate protection against salt spray and chemical exposure. These nails maintain their structural integrity and holding power throughout your roof’s entire lifespan.
Cost-Benefit Analysis for High-End Installations
Stainless steel nails typically cost 3-4 times more than standard galvanized options ($45-60 per pound versus $12-15). However, this premium investment eliminates the risk of fastener failure on high-end architectural shingles that often carry 30-50 year warranties. When installing luxury asphalt shingles worth $150-200 per square, the additional $30-40 spent on superior fasteners represents just 1-2% of your total roofing investment while potentially extending your roof’s effective lifespan by decades.
4. Aluminum Roofing Nails: The Lightweight Option
Aluminum roofing nails offer a compelling alternative for asphalt shingle installation, combining durability with significantly less weight than steel options. These lightweight fasteners provide excellent corrosion resistance while maintaining adequate holding power for most residential applications.
Compatibility with Different Shingle Types
Aluminum nails work exceptionally well with standard three-tab asphalt shingles and architectural shingles. Their smooth shanks penetrate easily without damaging shingle material, and their wide heads provide optimal surface contact. You’ll find they’re particularly suitable for lightweight laminate shingles where heavier nails might cause unnecessary stress on the roofing material.
Performance in Various Climate Conditions
Aluminum nails excel in coastal environments and high-humidity regions where corrosion resistance is crucial. They won’t rust or deteriorate when exposed to salt spray, making them ideal for oceanfront properties. You’ll notice they perform adequately in most temperature ranges but may not be the best choice for extreme freeze-thaw cycles, as they can be slightly less rigid than steel alternatives.
5. Copper Roofing Nails: Aesthetic Appeal Meets Functionality
Ideal Applications for Historic and Luxury Homes
Copper roofing nails excel in historic renovations and luxury home installations where aesthetics matter as much as performance. You’ll find these premium fasteners complement cedar shake, slate, and high-end architectural shingles perfectly. The distinctive copper finish creates harmony with period-authentic restorations and upscale projects where visible fasteners enhance rather than detract from the roof’s appearance. Many historic districts actually require copper nails for authenticity and preservation standards.
Weathering Characteristics and Long-Term Appearance
Copper nails develop a beautiful patina over time, transitioning from bright penny-color to rich brown and eventually classic verdigris blue-green. This natural aging process improves their appearance while maintaining structural integrity. You’ll appreciate how the weathering creates self-sealing protection against moisture intrusion. The patination process typically begins within months in coastal areas and may take 2-3 years in drier climates, with the fully developed patina providing decades of protection while enhancing architectural character.
Essential Tools and Techniques for Proper Nail Installation
Having the right tools and knowing proper installation techniques are crucial for ensuring your asphalt shingles remain securely fastened throughout their lifespan.
Nail Gun vs. Hammer: Pros and Cons
Pneumatic nail guns offer speed and consistency, driving nails at the perfect depth with each trigger pull. They’re ideal for larger projects but require compressor setup and cost more upfront. Hand hammering provides better feel and control, allowing you to adjust pressure based on decking conditions. It’s perfect for small repairs but significantly slower for full roof installations.
Correct Nail Placement for Maximum Shingle Protection
Place nails 1-1.5 inches above the cutout slots and 1 inch from each edge of the shingle. The industry-standard four-nail pattern creates optimal wind resistance and prevents shingle distortion. Nailing too high increases blow-off risk, while nailing too low leaves fasteners exposed to weather. Always follow manufacturer guidelines, as premium architectural shingles often require six nails in high-wind zones.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Selecting Roofing Nails
Choosing the wrong roofing nails can compromise your entire asphalt shingle installation. Even experienced roofers sometimes make these critical errors that lead to premature roof failure and costly repairs.
Sizing Errors and Their Consequences
Using nails that are too short prevents proper deck penetration, leading to shingles that lift in high winds. Conversely, excessively long nails may puncture underlayment or protrude through the decking into attic spaces. Always select nails that penetrate at least 3/4 inch into solid wood decking for optimal holding power while avoiding potential leak pathways.
Material Compatibility Issues to Watch For
Matching nail material to your local climate is essential for long-term performance. Aluminum nails will corrode when in contact with pressure-treated lumber, while standard galvanized nails fail prematurely in coastal environments. Using copper nails near galvanized metal creates galvanic corrosion that accelerates fastener deterioration. Always verify compatibility between your nail material, roofing components, and regional weather conditions.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Specific Roofing Project
Choosing the right roofing nails for your asphalt shingle installation isn’t just about buying fasteners—it’s about investing in your roof’s future. The best nail for your project depends on your specific climate conditions budget and the expected lifespan of your roofing materials.
Remember that premium options like stainless steel and copper nails offer superior longevity but come with higher upfront costs. For most standard installations galvanized or hot-dipped zinc-coated nails provide excellent value and reliable performance.
Whatever you choose proper installation technique remains critical. Using the right nail pattern and ensuring adequate deck penetration will maximize your roof’s wind resistance and weather protection. Your careful selection now will pay dividends through decades of reliable performance overhead.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best materials for roofing nails?
Hot-dipped galvanized steel and stainless steel are the top choices for roofing nails. For standard applications in moderate climates, hot-dipped galvanized nails provide excellent corrosion resistance for 20-25 years. Stainless steel nails offer superior longevity (50+ years) and are ideal for coastal areas, though more expensive. Aluminum nails work well in humid regions, while copper nails are perfect for historic renovations and luxury installations where aesthetics matter.
How long should roofing nails be for asphalt shingles?
Roofing nails for asphalt shingles should be long enough to penetrate at least 3/4 inch into the roof decking. For most residential applications, this typically means using 1-1/4 inch to 1-1/2 inch nails, depending on the thickness of your shingles and underlayment. Using nails that are too short can result in shingle blow-offs during high winds, while excessively long nails may protrude through the roof deck.
Are stainless steel nails worth the extra cost?
Yes, stainless steel nails are worth the investment, especially in coastal or high-humidity environments. Though they cost 3-4 times more than standard galvanized options, they provide unmatched corrosion resistance for 50+ years. For high-end architectural shingles with long warranties, the additional cost represents a small percentage of the overall roofing investment while potentially extending your roof’s effective lifespan by decades.
How many nails should be used per shingle?
Standard installation requires four nails per asphalt shingle, placed along the nailing strip according to manufacturer guidelines. In high-wind zones (120+ mph), six nails per shingle are recommended for enhanced wind resistance. Premium architectural shingles often have specific nailing patterns marked on each shingle. Always follow manufacturer instructions, as improper nail placement can void warranties and compromise roof integrity.
Can I use a nail gun for roofing installation?
Yes, pneumatic nail guns are ideal for roofing installation, offering speed and consistency. They deliver proper driving force and depth control, reducing the risk of over-driving or under-driving nails. While hand hammering provides better control for small repairs and detail work, nail guns significantly improve efficiency for larger projects. Ensure your nail gun is compatible with the specific roofing nails you’ve selected and properly adjusted for depth.
How do copper roofing nails compare to other options?
Copper roofing nails are premium fasteners that combine exceptional corrosion resistance with aesthetic appeal. Unlike standard options, they develop a distinctive patina over time—transitioning from bright copper to rich brown and eventually classic verdigris blue-green. While more expensive than galvanized nails, copper fasteners excel in historic renovations and luxury installations, particularly with cedar shake and slate materials. They offer decades of protection while enhancing architectural character.
What roofing nails work best in coastal environments?
For coastal environments, Type 316 stainless steel nails offer superior protection against salt spray and harsh conditions. Hot-dipped zinc-coated nails from brands like Maze, Grip-Rite’s GRHD series, or MAG-Nail’s coastal-grade options also perform well, lasting three times longer than standard galvanized nails in challenging conditions. Aluminum nails are another excellent choice, as they naturally resist salt-induced corrosion. The higher initial cost of these specialized nails is offset by their extended lifespan.
What are common mistakes when selecting roofing nails?
Common mistakes include choosing incorrect nail length (causing inadequate deck penetration or excessive protrusion), using incompatible materials that accelerate corrosion, selecting nails not rated for your climate zone, and opting for low-quality bargain nails that compromise roof integrity. Also, using smooth-shank nails instead of ring-shank varieties in high-wind areas significantly reduces holding power. Always verify that your nail choice meets both local building codes and manufacturer warranty requirements.
