5 Metal vs Asphalt Roofing Cost Benefits That Maximize Flip Profits
When you’re flipping houses, every dollar counts—and your roofing choice can significantly impact your bottom line. Metal and asphalt represent the two most common roofing options for investors, each with distinct cost implications that affect both your initial investment and long-term returns.
Understanding the financial benefits of metal versus asphalt roofing can make or break your profit margins on a flip. While asphalt shingles offer lower upfront costs that appeal to tight budgets, metal roofing’s durability and energy efficiency present compelling advantages that might justify the higher initial expense.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
1. Understanding the Initial Investment: Metal vs Asphalt Roofing Costs
Upfront Pricing Breakdown for House Flippers
Metal roofing typically costs $8-14 per square foot installed, while asphalt shingles run $3-5 per square foot. This significant price gap represents your primary consideration as a flipper. Architectural asphalt shingles cost 50-100% more than standard 3-tab varieties but still remain cheaper than metal. Material quality variations, regional labor rates, and roof complexity can further impact your initial investment.
Cost-Per-Square Analysis for Different Roof Sizes
A 1,500 square foot roof costs approximately $4,500-7,500 for asphalt versus $12,000-21,000 for metal. Smaller roofs (1,000 sq ft) show a narrower cost gap: $3,000-5,000 for asphalt compared to $8,000-14,000 for metal. Larger homes (2,500+ sq ft) demonstrate the most dramatic difference: $7,500-12,500 for asphalt versus $20,000-35,000 for metal roofing options.
2. Calculating Long-Term Value: Lifespan and Durability Differences
When flipping houses, looking beyond the upfront costs reveals significant long-term value differences between metal and asphalt roofing options.
Metal Roofing’s Extended Warranty Advantages
Metal roofs typically come with 40-50 year warranties compared to asphalt’s 15-30 year coverage. This extended protection translates to tangible value for buyers, allowing you to market the property with “lifetime roof” appeal. Many metal roofing manufacturers offer transferable warranties, which becomes a valuable selling point that can justify higher asking prices for your flip.
Weather Resistance Comparisons in Various Climates
Metal roofs outperform asphalt in extreme weather conditions, withstanding 140+ mph winds versus asphalt’s 110 mph threshold. In hail-prone regions, metal roofing’s impact resistance prevents costly damage, while in snow-heavy areas, metal’s slick surface sheds snow accumulation naturally. For coastal properties, aluminum metal roofing resists saltwater corrosion, maintaining integrity where asphalt often deteriorates within 12-15 years.
3. Weighing Installation Timelines and Labor Expenses
Quick Turnaround Benefits of Asphalt Installations
Asphalt shingles typically require just 1-3 days to install on an average home, making them ideal for tight flip schedules. The quick installation means your crew can move on to other renovation tasks faster, reducing project holding costs by up to 75% compared to metal roofing timelines. Most roofing crews are already experienced with asphalt installations, eliminating the learning curve that might delay your project.
Specialized Labor Requirements for Metal Roofing
Metal roof installations demand specialized skills and typically take 5-7 days to complete, adding significant labor costs. You’ll need certified metal roofers who command premium rates—often 30-50% higher than standard roofing crews. These specialized contractors are frequently booked weeks in advance, potentially creating costly schedule delays for your flip project and extending carrying costs.
4. Evaluating Energy Efficiency and Utility Savings
Metal Roofing’s Reflective Properties and Cooling Benefits
Metal roofs can reduce cooling costs by 10-25% compared to traditional asphalt shingles. The reflective surface of metal roofing redirects solar radiation rather than absorbing it, keeping your property significantly cooler during summer months. Even basic galvanized metal options outperform asphalt, while premium cool-roof coatings can reflect up to 85% of solar heat, making them especially valuable for properties in hot climates where cooling costs dominate utility bills.
Potential Tax Incentives and Rebates for Energy-Efficient Choices
Energy-efficient metal roofing may qualify for federal tax credits of up to $500 and local utility rebates ranging from $200-1,000. Many states offer additional incentives for energy-efficient building upgrades, including cool metal roofs that meet ENERGY STAR requirements. When flipping properties, these incentives can offset the higher initial investment while becoming a compelling selling point for energy-conscious buyers seeking lower monthly utility expenses.
5. Assessing Resale Value Impact and Buyer Perception
Market Analysis: Premium Pricing for Metal Roof Properties
Metal roofs consistently command premium resale values, with homes featuring metal roofing selling for an average of 6% higher than comparable properties with asphalt shingles. Real estate data shows that metal-roofed properties in upscale neighborhoods spend 10-15% less time on the market. This premium positioning is particularly pronounced in regions with extreme weather, where buyers recognize the added protection and durability metal roofing provides.
ROI Comparison Between Metal and Asphalt Investments
While metal roofing requires a higher initial investment ($12,000-21,000 vs. $4,500-7,500 for asphalt), it delivers superior ROI at 85-95% compared to asphalt’s 60-68%. The cost recovery timeline for metal typically falls between 5-7 years through combined energy savings and reduced maintenance. For flippers targeting quick turnarounds under 6 months, asphalt often makes financial sense despite its lower overall return potential.
6. Making the Final Decision: Which Roofing Material Maximizes Flip Profits
Selecting the right roofing material for your flip property ultimately depends on your specific investment strategy and timeline. For quick 3-6 month flips where immediate profit is the goal asphalt makes financial sense with its lower upfront costs and faster installation.
For premium market flips metal roofing provides compelling advantages despite higher initial investment. The 6% average price premium enhanced buyer appeal and substantial energy savings create a powerful value proposition for discerning buyers.
Remember to factor in your property’s location climate and target buyer demographics. Both options have their place in a flipper’s arsenal and the right choice will align with your investment goals market conditions and buyer expectations. Your roofing decision can significantly impact not just your current profit margins but also your reputation as a quality-focused investor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper, metal or asphalt roofing for house flips?
Asphalt shingles are significantly more budget-friendly upfront, costing approximately $3-5 per square foot compared to metal roofing’s $8-14 per square foot. For a standard 1,500 square foot roof, asphalt will cost around $4,500-7,500 while metal will run $12,000-21,000. The cost gap widens as roof size increases, making asphalt the clear choice for immediate budget constraints.
How long do metal roofs last compared to asphalt?
Metal roofs typically come with extended warranties of 40-50 years, while asphalt shingles generally last 15-30 years. This significant difference in longevity allows properties with metal roofs to be marketed with “lifetime roof” advantages, which can be a compelling selling point for potential buyers concerned about future replacement costs.
Are metal roofs more weather-resistant than asphalt?
Yes, metal roofs offer superior weather resistance. They can withstand winds exceeding 140 mph, resist impact from hail, shed snow effectively, and resist saltwater corrosion in coastal areas. Asphalt shingles are more vulnerable to extreme weather conditions and typically have lower wind resistance ratings, making metal a better choice for regions with severe weather patterns.
How do installation times compare between metal and asphalt roofs?
Asphalt shingles typically require just 1-3 days to install, making them ideal for tight house-flipping schedules. Metal roofing installations demand specialized skills and take 5-7 days to complete. The shorter installation time for asphalt can significantly reduce project holding costs, which is an important consideration for flippers working with strict timelines.
Do metal roofs provide energy savings?
Yes, metal roofs can reduce cooling costs by 10-25% compared to traditional asphalt shingles. Their reflective properties keep properties cooler during summer, with premium cool-roof coatings reflecting up to 85% of solar heat. Additionally, energy-efficient metal roofing may qualify for federal tax credits (up to $500) and local utility rebates ($200-1,000), making them appealing to energy-conscious buyers.
Which roofing material offers better resale value?
Homes with metal roofs sell for an average of 6% higher than those with asphalt shingles and spend 10-15% less time on the market, particularly in regions with extreme weather. Metal roofing delivers a superior ROI of 85-95% compared to asphalt’s 60-68%, with cost recovery typically occurring within 5-7 years.
Which roofing material is best for quick house flips?
For flippers targeting quick turnarounds under 6 months, asphalt shingles often make more financial sense despite their lower overall return potential. The significantly lower upfront cost, faster installation time (1-3 days vs. 5-7 days for metal), and wider availability of qualified installers make asphalt the practical choice for rapid flips focused on immediate returns.
Are there any tax incentives for metal roofing?
Yes, energy-efficient metal roofing may qualify for federal tax credits of up to $500 and local utility rebates ranging from $200-1,000. These financial incentives can help offset the higher initial investment cost of metal roofing and provide an additional selling point when marketing the property to environmentally conscious buyers.
